What are some YouTube channels which follow pre-monetisation ethos?
What are some YouTube channels which follow pre-monetisation ethos?
I'm looking for some small content creators who's content has not been influenced by the potential of making money. In the early days of YouTube there was mostly trash, but then a few small channels started using formats, using specific styles and actually standing out above a pile shit.
I used to love how these creators made their content for their viewers, they were so very different from anything we had in those days. Things have changed, I get it, everybody and their dog are trying to make money on the internet. Content creators need to pay bills, feed families and maintain/improve their quality. Honestly, I get it. But it sucks, I feel like 90% of the content I come across are contractually based to release at a specific time or interval. Meaning content creators are just milking their audience and sponsors. I'm not saying this type of content isn't good, it's just how it feels 10x less genuine and from the heart of the creator. (I feel LTT belongs in this category as well) It feels like cable television with extra steps and a personal algorithmic touch.
What people tend to forget is how little resources you need to make good quality content on youtube. It's never been easier to just start recording on our 4K+ smartphones. Yet, it's never been this hard to consistently find early internet ethos content creators.
So Lemmy, can you tell me about some small content creators whichhave the passion and drive we used to see?
I'll leave a few channels here which I enjoyed the most this past month.
Nokeric - Of the rails sketches
Joel Haver - Short sketches but also long form deep thought (Larger channel)
He has a patreon now but still no ads:
https://youtube.com/@primitivetechnology9550?si=lBWNPNLZowdKKR6i
Just a guy in the woods building shit from nothing, without tools. It kicked off a lot of similar channels that were obviously using tools.
I love these videos so much and cannot recommend them enough. No narrative, no music, no ads, just well placed camera shots to make the whole thing self explanatitory. I feel like I have learned so much from him and I have never heard his voice.
Yeah, he's really good. He's an Aussie fella, named (funnily enough) John Plant, although I guess that could be a pseudonym. I like his content and style so much, I really wanted to somehow pay him for the hours of enjoyment I've gotten, so I bought his book. Really good read.
I sort of like Mr. Chickadee for the same reason. No talking or flashy gimmicks, just hand tools and the sounds of nature.
If you’re at all into Minecraft, EthosLab is the gold standard for low-key, super interesting, and not driven by money videos. He’s not small, but he’s worth mentioning in case anyone hasn’t heard of him.
Get your snacks!
His minecraft series is the longest series I've ever watched. I've been watching since the Chocolate Island and Sgt Spaz days. So good.
I was going to suggest Direwolf20 for the exact same reasoning
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/channel/UC_ViSsVg_3JUDyLS3E2Un5g
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
Absolutely agree. He's one of the channels I've watched for the longest. Been subscribed since probably 2011 or so. His videos are just so wholesome and it always makes my day when he uploads. Absolutely recommend if people are into minecraft survival content.
My channel is not very good 😅 but I make videos just because I love talking about old video games and want an excuse to talk about them more. New videos come out every Tuesday and Saturday because that's when my co-host is off of work and can watch them with her mom. 🙂
Nothing wrong with a little self promotion! I do enjoy channels like The Retro Future as well, I'm sure I'll enjoy yours as well.
My kinda content! Giving you a follow!
Haha Thanks!
Louis Rossman. Right to repair is great
He's absolutely the best spokesperson for right to repair. Very knowledgeable and no-bullshit approach. Although I find he's becoming very complainy lately, not that there's not enough to complain about lmao, but sometimes I'm not in the mood for 15 min of heated ranting.
I find his voice so calming. Even when he's angry he sounds calm.
Beau of the fifth column does 3-10 minute videos doing political analysis in what looks like a garage.
He said on a longer FAQ video that he's set things up to hide his channel's income from himself. He draws a salary that's enough to take care of his family, but he doesn't know how much more the channel earns -- he doesn't want his content to be influenced even unconsciously by which videos The Algorithm say paid better.
Beau is a good one!
All of them with sponsorblock, which you then whitelist based on tolerability and quality.
I find that most content producers don't really actually let the sponsors get in the way of content in any capacity other than quantity (as in they produce too much for the channel's good). There's a small number of exceptions, but those usually stink enough that you spot it a mile away, and most of them intentionally. This isn't TikTok or Insta, Creators actually do want you to know when they didn't make something out of their own accord.
Some try to be more subtle with their one-off events... And into the blacklist they go back when they do. Unfortunately one of those was Kurszgesagt a month ago, with their blatantly biased and fearmongering video on Bioweapons, which was largely based on one non-scientific source. Funny enough, they did seem to a leave a hard to notice hint that the video was off, I mean, aside from the content. The hint was that: The video had no birds. You know, their mascots.
Them being sponsored is not the issue here, contrary to popular belief, you can actually be sponsored AND unbiased. But listen to many different creators and you'll notice a trend in burnout, chasing the next viral video, having to meet deadlines for sponsors, etc. All these things can and will deteriorate the viewing experience.
I follow plenty of creators, doing so full-time and only with the support of their fans, it's a well thought out, proven system and it works. Almost all of them started before any monetisation was possible as well. It's amazing how something like that is even possible.
All that being said, there's a definite decline in passion and drive across the board. I still enjoy all the new produced content, but in the same way I enjoy a movie or TV show. Much less in a "we're a community of like minded people" kind of way.
My problem with sponsorship isn't about bias, it's about annoying sponsored segments.
+1 to sponsor block. It's a game changer in today's YouTube.
That being said, it is still frustrating that most YouTubers nowadays censor the fuck out of their videos in fear of being cancelled by the YouTube algorithm or the sponsors. I appreciate when I come across a channel that still has the balls to say "fuck" or use normal words that people now suddenly view as "trigger" words like "kill" or use a squirt gun without censoring it.
I don't mean that every video needs to be laden with profanity and shock content, but just that I want it to be normal, relaxed, and genuine. Not some stupid squeaky clean version of content that only 10 year old children in Catholic school are allowed to watch. I'm a grown ass adult goddamnit.
Cold Ones is a bit of an obnoxious channel, but I appreciate that they don't bend to the will of YouTube's stupid censorship for the most part.
Generally though I prefer to watch reaction YouTubers. Sixteenleo has fantastic long form content (hour+ long videos) doing deep dive reaction videos. He doesn't have a loud, obnoxious vibe that many channels do either. I like his relaxed vibe and long form content.
"Hello. My name is, your host, ... The Crafsman."
The CrafsMan SteadycCaftin is the most chill, honest, and entertaining crafting/toymaking/music-making channel anywhere.
There's some outstanding science content out there. My newest find is Three Twentysix, a 2.5k-subscriber chemistry channel. I've already learned some new stuff from him that I hadn't seen from The Professor or Nile Red.
I have a big list of favorites that I've shared recently, really solid creators, but that's my hot tip for the day.
Good suggestion, thanks! Edutainment is very hot right now, honestly the future of education in some ways.
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/channel/UCXayhlRaDUhfJOtuSLgz-7w
https://piped.video/channel/UCtESv1e7ntJaLJYKIO1FoYw
https://piped.video/channel/UCFhXFikryT4aFcLkLw2LBLA
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
If you want more chemistry stuff check out Prussian Blue. His videos are pretty funny and kinda feel like Mr. Green in more serious.
Amateur Chemistry is also pretty funny although his videos are more amateurish
Also ThyLabs. His videos are pretty high quality.
I have to tell you about Bobby Broccoli. He makes high quality videos about fraud/scandals in science. All his videos are well researched and have a unique style you won't find anywhere else on the internet. One of his recent documentaries (about fraud in stem cell/cloning research) was so good, Netflix straigt up copied it
And his style is so damn good with a single uniform Blender image that grows as the story develops. It's destined to be copied by other video editors in the next few years.
Hell yeah, love that guy
I'm not sure all of these are really small content creators and completely sponsor free but here it is:
YT channel on STEM and making sciency stuff: https://youtube.com/@TechIngredients?si=ic6g-uCLEWXO4DWu
Random technical stuff : https://youtube.com/@TechnologyConnections?si=sz-Gwfgo0gMN3vOG
All things space genuine expert: https://youtube.com/@scottmanley?si=MzE-v1thBOwrvmBf
Great computer stuff: https://youtube.com/@Computerphile?si=S2Ju7aLhViNw5sd8
Not so unnecessary inventions: https://youtube.com/@UnnecessaryInventions?si=O9iy4OVVbhJj6-kE
Some scottish guy researching odd history stuff: https://youtube.com/@CalumRaasay?si=UqgnEsN0YkU7YZuR
This guy sounds ! https://youtube.com/@LOOKMUMNOCOMPUTER?si=9lN-vhpOO-twS6pi
Pretty random list, I just like very different kind of things :)
But I'd say most of the above are passionate people and mostly without ads or sponsors etc.
LOOKMUMNOCOMPUTER is honestly one of the best channels I've found this year, the guy's energy is amazing, and the journey of his organ is definitely worth watching. I'll check out the other channels for sure!
Prozd and Magic the Noah.
Prozd is mostly "Here's a boardgame i reviewed. Now look here's a skit!"
Magic the Noah just bullshits around coming up with boardgames that he forces other small content creators to play.
Prozd does plenty of sponsored skits and videos. And it is very much a portfolio for his va work.
Which is how these threads go. It is just "what channels do you like"
I mean yes. Ofc. But that is how it always has been. He was a VA before he started youtube. But the format and the irregularity of when he posts is not of the money making kind.
I think sponsored content is impossible to get away from but prozd has mostly stayed the same since he started youtube.
ProZD has been arround! Definitely enjoyed him, I'll check the other channel out as well, thank you.
Hbomberguy and MattKC come to mind for me. Also, but this is very niche, most of the Brickfilming scene still feels this way, there's just no money to be made in there.
I'm surprised no one has mentioned Cody's Lab. He's been on YouTube for a very long time, never seen him have ads or do sponsors or anything. He also frequently gets screwed over by YouTube due to his content (lots of chemistry) but has always managed to keep making videos.
Yes. He said youtube hasn’t paid him in a very long time
Big fan as well!
Hardly a small channel, but VlogBrothers still make videos like it’s 2008. They don’t even ask you to like, comment, and subscribe, never mind mid-video ad reads for World of Warships or Scottish Titles.
And they have figured out how to have enough. So much of their stuff sends all the profits to charity.
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/user/vlogbrothers
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
Project Farm is probably the foremost tool/gear testing and review channel. No sponsors, he always buys what he tests with his own money, and all of the testing ideas come from the community. This dude is one of the hardest working content creators and makes great videos that serve a valuable purpose.
One of my favorites is Atomic Shrimp. He does his own thing creating videos on weird stuff he loves doing. Videos include scambaiting, reviewing cans of strange foods, nature and slowtv videos, cooking meals from ingredients bought with limited budgets and rules, food, gardening, and crafting experiments, cheap dropship item reviews, etc.
I've never seen a sponsored ad from him and he avoids using clickbaity thumbnails and titles. His content isn't for everyone, but I thoroughly enjoy watching all the random shit he does.
Edit: also, I just read over his channel description, he blatantly says he does not accept any offers for sponsorships, paid ads, product placements, etc. Definitely fits your "not for the money" question! :)
First name that came to mind when I saw the thread title. His new Weird Stuff in a Can episode was a fun journey.
Beau Miles. Makes beautiful little documentaries voiced over with his beautiful Australian accent.
Amazing suggestion, what a gem
Civvie 11 has a Patreon, but he never begs ya to support him, doesn't take sponsors (even makes fake sponsor skits to make fun of sponsors), and he just delivers his content with no intention on letting monetization get in the way. Worst he's done is display a card saying "midroll ad goes here."
As for his content, it's sort of a hybrid review/let's play of old first person shooters, new first person shooters inspired by those of old, hilariously inept first person shooters, and Slavjank. His humor is fantastic, editing is tight, and there's a sort of back story going on in the background of his videos that he could not be more interested in getting involved in (in character, mind.)
I watched pro postal a while ago and it was pretty good. I'll watch more of his content.
I do appreciate creators who do their own content despite being keenly aware of the algorithm.
Infrequent long-form content creators to check out:
Tom O'Regan: British(?) topical/interest reviews, personal recommendations include his Obra Dinn video, Sickest Chess Match, and The Biggest Mistake In Music History
B-Mask: I support him on Patreon so pardon the bias but he likes to take his time creating in-depth and clear retrospectives on topics he's interested in, managing to get you interested in The Fantastic Four, Jems, and 2000s video game trilogies. Not long form for the sake of $$$ but insightful analysis of the history, themes, and personal deconstruction of such topics.
Also check out Moth Light Media for evolutionary biology, and Lines in Motion for manga and art analysis.
More frequent but short form (under 4 minutes) creators to check out are few and wide, 5sf are back-ish but carrying the torch are:
CrackerMilk are a bunch of good aussie lads making short sketches for quick laughs, with excellent timing and shooting.
Valueselect is a personal fave where he was doing sketches a year or two ago but is experimenting with yt shorts quite well. The majority of his comedy surrealist/fantasy/80's styling music are absolute hits.
Hope these are good starting points, I found these guys from browsing similar threads.
https://www.youtube.com/@post.10
just a dude unclogging culverts, living in the moment
no ads, no begging to subscribe, nothing, just pure raw content
Lmao, thank you. Unironically just people doing their jobs is great content. Powerwashing, yard cleaning, wood building, etc
Can't recommend Posy enough https://youtube.com/@PosyMusic?si=Ea2_2-mgE_58dvKa
His style is /amazing/. Beautiful images and music with soothing voice over
A cool starting video would be this one: https://youtu.be/eGQQWIbD-nM?si=0AqB6o4T09wza9vf
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/eGQQWIbD-nM?si=0AqB6o4T09wza9vf
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
Permanently Deleted
I've got some, but they're not small.
There's callmekevin for game plays, but it's done in the worst way possible. (Rtgame, too. They're friends and have videos together)
Stephen tries' main channel. He does comedy sketches. But may not land as well if you're not from England.
And, one I haven't seen people mention, Kurzgesagt. Some people have issues from them for talking about things that may be influenced. And they've got big sponsors like Bill Gates. But, when you actually watch them, that whole kerfuffle just doesn't make sense because of what they talk about. They do educational videos, and their art style is the best I've honestly seen.
Bill Wurtz
I mainly make game reviews and I often get comments shocked at how I only have 600 subs, so go check me out if you have the time. I just made an hour long video about Pokemon Crystal a few weeks ago lol.
For videogame gameplays, I like 2BSkyen. It's a secondary channel of his (his main ones being TBSkyen and TBSkyenShorts or something like that) and I tend to find that secondary channels are the ones that are usually less plagued by chasing trends and sponsored stuff. In his main channels he has a focus in character design but I like him because he's sort of an all-rounder: he's insightful, knows a bit about everything and is much more eloquent than the average youtuber. I also like that he wears his progressive politics on his sleeve and that he's not scared of playing like a patient gamer and reading the lore. He's also a bit of an insider in the videogame industry and sometimes shares interesting stuff regarding that.
If you like to discover indie games, I have two channels for you: Wanderbots and Splattercatgaming. The first one is a progressive guy that explores all kinds of indie games (but I do think he likes bullet heavens and turret defense games because there's a lot of those), he also sometimes plays with his wife and friends. The second one has quite a high quality channel and he periodically revisits what feels like every single RPG and/or strategy and/or roguelite and/or space related indie game out there giving his insights on each version of them along their development. Both of these channels tend to play just a bit of the game, not full walkthroughs: that way you can choose if you'd like to play the actual game yourself and support indie devs.
My last gameplay channel recommendation would be MKIceAndFire. Now I don't know if this fits your criterium exactly because he does very much upload the latest mainstream games the second they come out, and very often before they do because game companies seem to give him early access. The reason for that is that it's the biggest no commentary gameplay channel in YT. So... it kinda feels like and old school YT channel if you used to watch no commentary let's plays on YT, which is something that I did. And if there's a mainstream game I want to watch that I know I won't find an insightful letsplayer playing it... then I know I can watch it in MKIceAndFire. It's not often that I need him, but he's always there. He also has a lot of Mortal Kombat and fighting game videos if that's your thing.
For non gameplay channels, there's a number I follow that do their own thing and disregard the algorithm:
-
Brian David Gilbert: He just does weird song videos, his humor is kinda 2000s YT.
-
Errant Signal: He does good video essays analyzing videogames, usually indie ones. He also has a phenomenal series he has been slowly building lately called Children of Doom which I absolutely recommend if you like videogame history. I don't even like FPS games and I found it entrancing.
-
New Frame Plus: The guy does video essays on videogame animations. I particularly like his Final Fantasy ones, where he goes through the animation of every FF game starting from the first one, and the Best Game Animation of the Year where he shoutouts a lot of noteworthy animation in videogames for the whole year. I like how it feels he loves and relishes every single detail of animation work.
-
Innuendo Studios: This one doesn't upload very often but he does interesting political essays on the alt right from a leftist perspective.
.
BTW anyone reading this that made it to here: if you have channels you would recommend me based on the things I've said I like I'd love to hear it.
I haven't watched splattercat that much but I do like his channel to discover new stuff. What makes you say he's not progressive? I don't remember hum saying anything even close to political.
Oh I think I just worded it poorly. English is not my native language. I took it out now, but basically I meant that while Wanderbots has shown to be explicitly progressive a couple of times, Splattercatgaming has not. Actually now that I think about it when there's explicit moral/ideological decisions in-game he does tend to pick the most "right-wing" ones, but I know that shouldn't be posited as indicative of anything IRL. Like in this one (link to the video but also to a comment from someone else highlighting how he usually does just that).
-
Conedodger240 Kurtjmac
After all these years they're still small enough that I feel a connection. These guys aren't making millions. They're getting by and trying to be genuine.
@kernelle Ross Scott
I've been trying to figure out why Bess never hit it big for years now. She does some of the most cutting anime analysis you can find. Though her body of work is still fairly small, admittedly.
Example, diving into the Madoka Magica debate: https://youtu.be/n_71AJSpDPI?si=4qrYjpseohnWJ7iu
Away from the edutainment and tech based stuff, I like Decino. Just a guy that really likes playing old school Doom. He doesn't do the whole exaggerated reactions or yelling or anything like that and I don't think I've ever heard him plug any kind of sponsor or product. It's great to put on in the background or just watch casually if you're into it
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/_OHeOxLS_Ps?si=BbP3EcGBG2ead76_
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
Physics Videos by Eugene Khutoryansky
Not really a small YouTuber with just under 1 mill subs, but he's a good example of someone just doing their own thing. Super bizarre videos, but incredibly well made at the same time.
Chuggaconroy and TRG have pretty much kept up their quality over 20 years at this point, specially Chuggaconroy. He specializes in Nintendo games, and he's known for doing borderline encyclopedic let's plays, such as 100% Xenoblade chronicles. TRG meanwhile is just three guys hanging out and having fun. Just a fair warning, Chugga in particular has very high energy. Not obnoxious, like Mr.Beast or other high content YouTubers, but he's known for having extremely high energy moments. His newer content is much more mellow.
LGR is the same he's ever been.
Callum is making some of the most interesting videos I've found on YouTube in while
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/c/CalumRaasay
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
Cathode Ray Dude is amazing for weird old tech stuff!
Dime Store Adventures makes videos about discovering and researching minor historical events.
One of my favorites is when he heard a local legend about the reason one gravestone in a small cemetery is much larger than all the rest. The legend was that the man hated his family so much that he decided to exhaust his estate with the most expensive gravestone possible. He shows how he figures out whether it was true by reading old newspapers and visiting historical societies.
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/H0NWn-ytoqI?si=AzfgpSzlfG2fnvKF
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
Even though he has over 35 million subscribers, I'd say Markiplier is pretty darn genuine with his content. He has brand deals every once in a while, but most of his stuff is just him goofing around playing games with his friends.
Theres some great videos on peertube if you want some of their content.