Skip Navigation

Is it a thing in the US to eat other spreads than peanut butter such as (crunchy) chocolate spread on bread?

Hi I'm from Germany and I recently discovered these different spreads other than peanut butter here that I found quite tasty.

One was a peanut butter chocolate spread from Reese's who also makes my favorite candy Reese's peanut butter cups.

And I found a chocolate cream that's like Nutella but with crunchy pieces mixed in like the one in the image (tastes like Ovaltine powder or Whoppers candy and 55% of the ingredients is just sugar).

Nutella (/hazelnut spread) of course is very popular here but I rarely eat it. As a kid I used to love and be obsessed with this cookie butter from Lotus.

Other spreads I know would be Dulce de leche which is caramel flavored and popular in Latin America.

Is that something Americans would eat or does this sound very exotic/weird and they mostly stick to standard peanut butter?

23 comments
  • We like Nutella.

    I'd try this. Though I am not a fan of crunchy peanut butter, chocolate and malt ball pieces would be awesome.

    In California, at least, dulce de leche is also pretty common, though usually on desserts or in drinks; not so much on toast.

  • In the north east US, there's a marshmallow spread called Fluff, which is usually paired with peanut butter on toast and called a fluffer nutter.

  • We have something called apple butter, which is a very dark thick applesauce spread.

    Edit: you call it applestroop

  • Other things? Yes. This thing? Absolutely not. Closest thing would be Hazelnut spread (such as Nutella), which I'm pretty sure is just a gelatinous chocolate.

  • The only other spread that I've seen people eat is Nutella, a sugary hazelnut spread. Outside of PB&Js, of course.

23 comments