Post with 22k upvotes mentions Lemmy as an alternative to Reddit
Posted in r/BuyFromEU by u/lukakopajtic • 33,275 points and 2,033 comments
You're viewing a single thread.
And as usual, the top comment related to Lemmy is people complaining about bad UX
Let's keep guiding them to better UX
Let's keep guiding them to better UX
Like PieFed's:-)
What mobile app works nicely with it?
None, that's the main issue. They are working on a Thunder fork
I don't think PieFed has mobile apps yet, but I believe they're planning on forking Thunder for Lemmy.
Yea, that's a problem, I feel without a decent mobile app it would be a worse UX for many users. Until they have mobile app options I'll keep directing users to something like Voyager for mobile or phtn.app for desktop
For recommendations to people on Reddit, PieFed's app support is "coming soon", but if you want more details personally, they are here.
Edit: Also, PieFed has a number of features that make it work more like the Voyager app than the Lemmy web UI, e.g. the Tile view. I also like how PieFed makes the community side-bar text so readily visible, placing it below every single post (like if you were going to reply you'd be on that page), in contrast to Voyager or Lemmy web UI where you first have to navigate to the community page and then ask for the side-bar to be displayed. Nothing is perfect ofc, but there are a number of ways that using PieFed in a browser is very much like or even better than (some? I have only tried Voyager iirc) Lemmy apps.
Some users want apps, and it's a strict requirement. I don't get it, but they are quite vocal about it
I don't disagree at all, but I also think it's important to keep the conversation focused on the benefits. eg: "I'm happy to trade Reddit's UI for a platform that doesn't encourage toxic behavior" (and so on).
EDIT: The threadiverse will not ever be Reddit and we won't be able to please everyone, I think it's important to portray confidence in the platform and not get bogged down defending the (less important) flaws.
Let’s keep guiding them to better UX
I've been trying the Photon/Voyager approach, the issue is that some people despise Photon and modernist interfaces with a passion, there's a comment on that thread I had to link to old.lemmy.zip
I don't get why someone would hate Photon. It's a great interface, beautifully constructed and organized. Overall, great to use.
Wait, are you the real Blaze?
Interface are always a very debatable topic.
Well, yes, I mean I'm the one people usually see around here, not sure if that's what you mean by "the one"
Nevermind. I was using a different app so I didn't recognised you.
Reminds me of this:
You watch Jehtt too? Amazing guy! I used to help with captions to his channel. Too bad the Discord server for that died…
Heck yeah his videos always had me laughing on the floor I loved the one where knuckles brought in a knock off sonic and Silver yelled at him 🤣
Aw dang that’s too bad about the discord server.
"Can I be real with you?" "Sure." "Thanks." - 🦔
I've been focused lately on changing some UI aspects of Photon to please both sides, compact mode is now comparable to old reddit (while looking good) and it's the default. People who like them can switch to the cozy interface on their own.
Great!
Personally, I'm OK with technical hurdles like "not using .com like a normal website" keeping the people who think any website domain should be .com off the platform.
Reddit got worse as it got more popular. Especially once it crossed the threshold of being popular enough to be worth investing time and money into making bots that could be easily confused with normal people, whether for advertising, scamming, or disinformation purposes.
I would agree with the bad UX point. But I totally disagree on the "lemmy.com" URL. The instance thing isn't really hard to understand, all I had to do was to search for a tutorial that was available on GitHub. This person seems to be raging too hard.
