What user was banned doing this initially?

Well, why don't you just cover yourself in dish soap and pretend it's fragrance if you know so much?!

Besides Silver Wind, it also bears a resemblance to Cavalli Black, which is also long discontinued. I need to get a sample of Rossa Black to do a full comparison.

Luna Rossa Black always reminds me of Dsquared's excellent He Wood Silver Wind Wood, with the primary exceptions being that LRB is smoother and more tonka-y while SWW has a pronounced incense note that makes things a little more rough and dirty. Both are beautiful scents in my opinion.

Silver Wind Wood has been discontinued, but since it's not a big hype scent you should easily be able to score bottles (or samples) for a decent price.