I'm re-watching The Magicians with my wife, since she's never seen it. It's been long enough since I watched it last that I don't remember a lot of things that happened, so there's a lot of "I forgot got that!" moments for me, which is fun.
It's a great show, I'm sure you'll enjoy it. Very well written and acted.
Timothy Olyphant and Walton Goggins are fantastic but there's also a recurring character, Wynn Duffy, played by Jere Burns, and I love almost every scene he's in.
There's also a weird amount of cast overflow between my three shows in minor supporting roles. Maybe that's true for most shows and it's just that these three I return to.