"The Midwest"

Only three of those green states are in the Midwest, though.

You think this is BS?

West Virginia isn't even the furthest west Virginia... And there are only 2 of them.

I'm not from the US and this thread is the first time I've understood why the phrase "the Midwest" never seemed to match up with where I thought "the Midwest" should be.

Once upon a time the USA promised various tribes we would not start settling their lands to the west so the "midwestern USA" did match that space until we violated treaties and later seized CA.
Basically we had more land that wasn't ours to the west when the midwest got it's name.

Put the center of the compass in NY and it all works.

This. Our country was originally established on the east coast. Anything off the coastline was considered "west." But knowing just how massive our country is now, we have the true west (left half of the country) and then the mid-west (anything not on the east coast, but not on the left half of the country).
Our basis for cardinal locations is centered around the concept of our nation slowly expanding "out west" from the east coast.

Sorry bud, this is CartographyAnarchy, not just plain Cartography. Please post such accurate maps there rather than this joke place :)

That’s upper/north MidEast.

Remember how the Atlanta Braves and Cincinnati Reds were in the Western Division of the National League? I remember it sticking out like a sore thumb. Same division teams, ATL vs LA or SD or SF on opposite ends of four, count 'em, four timezones.

EDIT: Then the Chicago Cubs were on the Eastern Division of the National League, while the White Sox were on the Western Division of the American.

It was really strange. Thankfully things were slightly better by the 90s when the central division was added, but that still had weird groupings like Houston/Pittsburgh (or Miami/Montreal).

I didn't look up where Guam and American Samoa are. The centre could even be further west.

But new York is in the south.

I’m from WA and NY is much warmer than WA, defy makes sense to me
Where's US Chad?

We should rename it the "middle east"

This is because names are with relation to the center of power.
So to europeans, the middle east is well, middle east, from europe.
While to east coast americans, the midwest is well, the middle west, compared to the original colonies.
This is what happens when you use naming systems from the powerful instead of just using local names.
- So to europeans, the middle east is well, middle east, from europe.
  Europe splits it into "near east" (Turkey, UAE, Iran), "middle east" (Afghanistan, India) and "far east" (China).
- Sort of? The fact is when the midwest got its name there was land to the west America had not claimed/seized/stolen.
i was about to say that this its like calling West Asia the "Middle East".
or one of the easternmost indian states being called "West Bengal".
- For the latter it is because the East Bengal is the independent country of Bangladesh
Haliburton has entered the chat.
- Haliburton has rebuilt the chat.

I’m assuming it was named that way because “the west” was basically anything past Oklahoma from the perspective of the east coast, where most of the population existed.

Everything past the Ohio Valley was considered the west.

Did Canada take back the top bit at some point?
- Ceded by treaty: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_1818
- Yup

It was the west before the entire Continent was explored. For you youngsters there was a time when they didn't know where the other side of the landmass was.

And by "they", we mean invaders from Europe, specifically.
- I highly doubt that Native Americans from the east coast knew where the west coast was, either.

Yeah as a Kansan I always just assumed I was Midwest since… well… I’m as mid as it gets…

I recognize that I’m Central and not west though , feels like Midwest should really be Colorado/Nevada etc. Certainly doesn’t make any sense for those northeastern states to be called Midwest though.

As a native Oklahoman, the term always confused hell out of me.
- It really shouldn't. It's a historical name. Most people lived in the east and came west.