Skip Navigation
79 comments
  • It's considered rude.

    As a girl, my job isn't to look attractive to guys. I smile when I feel like it, which happens a lot because I'm happy, but I'd still consider it rude if anyone told me to smile like it was an order. If you're a guy and you wouldn't tell other guys to smile in the same context, then that falls under discrimination based on sex.

    1. Context matters. That question is rarely asked by anyone that isn’t a douchebag trying to hit on a woman.
    2. From my understanding, even when NOT in the context of douchebaggery, it’s a condescending thing to say to a woman. So much of society wants to put women in a box where they’re expected to look pretty, smile more, talk less, and listen to big strong men with their big manly brains. Being told to “smile more” is pretty triggering for some (but maybe not all) women who are tired of dealing with that shit.

    Disclaimer: am man, as my username implies.

  • This was posted 4 times, you may want to remove the duplicates.

    I would agree that people look better when they smile, but I think that it is considered sexist because women are asked to smile where men are not, in similar situations. I believe that women feel it is controlling, and since it's requested/required of women more often then men, their perspective is that it is sexist.

    Would you feel okay with a woman asking you to flex? I would, but if it became something that happened on a regular basis, I think it would quickly become annoying to me.

    • I just removed the dupes, thanks. Fedia was being glitchy.

      Plus, you explained your answer well.

  • It's a weird thing to say in general. Would you say that to a man?

    • I’ve never said it to anyone (well, except when taking a group photo). You’re right; it’s weird. I’m just looking for perspectives on why it’s weird.

      • It’s weird because it sets you up as the objective authority on what makes them attractive.

        With another man, that just comes across as a neutral weird. With a woman, it comes across with a bunch of historical and cultural baggage tied to how a large number of men treat women, and automatically associates you with that group of misogynists.

  • I don't know if it's sexist but it sure as hell is annoying. Don't tell people to smile if you don't have a very good reason.

  • I think you should ask men to smile more (like at the grocery store or gym) and see how it goes. 😉

    • I don’t feel that need, and don’t tell people to “smile more” because I don’t understand why it’s problematic. I’m getting a clearer idea, though.

  • Do you have an example?

    The only time I can imagine someone asking someone else to smile is when taking photos.

    • I don’t have an example because I knew it wasn’t a good thing to do, so I didn’t (and won’t!) do it. I just didn’t know why, but those who have responded have helped explain!

  • I initially didn't understand the context of the question as I assumed you meant when taking a photo.

  • I taught my dog to smile. "Smile pretty"and she would bare her fangs for a treat

79 comments