Skip Navigation
92 comments
  • I wouldn't outwardly say that I hate anime but I definitely assume the worst when I hear a show is one. I automatically start thinking it's going to be style over substance with unnecessarily long fight scenes, unrelatable characters, gross sexualization of female characters (if not child characters), and awkward dubs.

    There are obviously exceptions to this. Serial Experiments Lain was my PFP here on Lemmy for a while and it's one of my favorite shows ever. Within the past month I binged all of Chainsaw Man in two nights and thought it was great. But it was great in spite of the fact that it's also an anime

  • I don't think people straight up hate anime, nobody is going to pick up a remote and turn of the TV if they see somebody else watching it and angrily leave the room.

    It's just, for the most part (and this is also true for non-animated movies or series), you've seen one you've seen them all.

    There are only so many times you can tell the story of boring guy gets put in fantasy land and is not boring anymore, or mysterious things happen at school and the afterschool mystery club has to solve them.

    So what do you do? You cling to what you know is good. Studios, directors, etc. If Miyazaki makes an anime movie you watch it, if Quentin Terentino makes an action movie you watch it. This is also partially why anime's are less popular than mainstream movies and series. You can watch a movie solely because you like an actor/actress, regardless of whether they play the same character or somebody else. In anime, each new series has a new set of characters, so each time a new personal connection has to be built.

    Other than that, a good measure of "is this worth my time?" is pop cultural representation. Rule of thumb, if an anime spawns memes, it's usually half decent.

    But just like with movies and series, there are timeless classics. Like, who hasn't seen or at least heard of Cowboy Bebop, Evangelion, Trigun, Dragon Ball Z, etc.. Even my parents know Pokemon. Those have been around for so long and been shown on mainstream western channels during prime time slots, that they were impossible to miss. I think people who aren't familiar with those are just not that interested in motion picture as a whole, regardless how its presented.

    I'd say without overeaching, anime's can be put in just a few categories:

    • Artistic, Philosophical, Experimental, Parodies: Those are your Miyazaki films, Ghost in the Shell, Evangelion, One Punch Man, Full Metal Alchemist, Attack on Titan, etc.
    • Long running: Like, Pokemon, One Piece, Naruto, Dragon Ball, the Fate Series
    • Trying to sell you something: Again Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh, Gundam, Beyblade, etc.
    • Mass produced trash: All the ones where the title spreads 3 lines and tells you 90% of the story
    • Otaku soap operas: The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, the Monogatari series, Nagatoro, Komi-San

    But those categories are not evenly spread in appeal, quality and quantity. While the first 2 categories have barely any presence but arguably the most cultural impact, the later ones have the most presence but are individually culturally insignificant. But quality is harder to judge than quantity is to see. So people tend to see the mass produced trash and ignore the good stuff that is being overshadowed. With classical film, a movies intention can usually be discerned with just one look, if for example a modern movie is black and white, its usually artistic. But looking at things like Evangelion, or the Ghost in the Shell Series, you couldn't guess the deep philosophical implications on first glance. People tend to see cutesy anime art style and associate it with either the mass produced trash, or shows made for children. What makes a film/series good is the intention and execution, if it happens to be animated this usually doesn't take away from the underlying message. See old animated Disney Movies - Lilo and Stich is about Family Values, Monetary Struggles, Loss and Friendship. Adult topics packed in a medium that both children and their parents can enjoy.

    People tend to hate anime for the same reason they hate superhero movies, they see the overarching medium, but not the individual pieces. You can't compare the significance of Iron Man 1 with Thor 2, or Infinity War with The Marvels, some of these movies are good in a vacuum, without the whole Cinematic Universe attached to them. Same goes for anime, some are simply good stories regardless of them being animated.

  • I generally don't talk about it, but because you asked, I have seen a lot of anime and hate most of it. I have seen Hellsing, Hellsing Ultimate, about 9/10 of the OG run of Fullmetal Alchemist, a lot of Ranma 1/2, Serial Experiments Lain, Akira, some Death Note, La Blue Girl, some tennis one I can't remember the name of, Castlevania, a few Studio Ghibli movies, Attack on Titan S1 & 2, random episodes of Samurai Pizza Cats, all of One Punch Man, Interspecies Reviewers, Slayers, some DiC Sailor Moon, some early Pokemon, and a few Dragonball, YuGiOh, Digimon, and Naruto episodes.

    I don't count early GI Joe or Transformers even though they're technically anime, but I didn't like those either.

    Of those, I liked Interspecies Reviewers, about 1.5 seasons of OPM, 1 season of Castlevania, and Hellsing Abridged (because it's fucking hilarious).

    Here's a random top 10 of reasons:

    1. Anime has a horrible habit of having a great premise, a lot of repeated setup, and then zero payoff followed by a new season escalating with the same. In short, great at premise, poor at developing it into a story. And endings? They have no idea how to end a series except for fighting bigger bad guys...
    2. And that's IF they can even be arsed to finish a series. I'm aware of the timeframe dynamic between manga and anime. It fucked over Game of Thrones too. Maybe we just agree not to start a show before the source material is done?
    3. Much of the animation looks abysmal and the "serious" ones seem to have an awful habit of just... panning over a background or frozen characters in a scene for fucking ever to fill time. I made note of this during Serial Experiments Lain to my friend who was making me watch it and it basically ruined the show for him. It completely wrecked the pacing and was done CONSTANTLY. There were 45 second pans (which I would start audibly counting after 10 seconds) while the main character just monologued "I'm 12 and this is deep" bullshit that was nearly completely disconnected from the plot. There was no reason to do this. Even recent shows like Castlevania did this.
    4. Shit just happens that doesn't make any sense in context of the world they've set up. This is endemic from anime I've seen. Anime fans think that randomness is "creative" instead of just "throwing shit at a screen because the writer had a fever dream and it doesn't matter at all if it makes any fucking sense". Spirited Away is basically just this. No, randomness is not creativity, Katy the Penguin of Doom.
    5. They're just a different set of tropes than American cartoons, many of which I find to be nonsensical, twee, or cringe-inducing. Bloody nose when you get a boner trope, I'm looking at you.
    6. I fucking hate Japanese voice acting (and often for the most part the Americans who dub it, especially in kids shows). This started when Sailor Moon came over and I wanted to kill everyone in the immediate vicinity whenever most of the characters spoke. That shrill panic screaming that was in SM and Pokemon was awful.
    7. In the same vein, I also can't stand constant "reaction sounds". Someone saying something mildly surprising that you should have easily realized 10 episodes ago isn't an excuse to stare blankly and make an "AH", "OH", or "UH" noise (sometimes followed by a small choking sound) roughly four hundred times per episode. Humans don't do this.
    8. They make movies that just do random shit and don't have anything to do with the show (if not outright contradict the show). Dragonball is especially notorious for this.
    9. A really weird number of them throw in Nazis seemingly at random, appropriate time and setting be damned. Need a bad guy? Fucking Nazis!
    10. I am constantly inundated with friends that like anime telling me that I should watch whatever their new anime obsession is despite it conforming to 3/4 of bad things on this list because obviously I just haven't watched the right anime.
  • I'm generally picky about how I spend large amounts of time. As an adolescent I watched like 700 episodes of One Piece but I eventually gave up. At this point I can't be bothered with any Shonen; they're the equivalent of junk food. Even Mob Psycho 100 started getting tiresome in season 3.

    I've never appreciated bishoujo/harem garbage; I had coworkers that watched it regularly and it was very off-putting. They are horny and delusional, pretending there is substance.

    But I still think there's a lot of solid art in manga/anime. I tend to look for popular seinen manga that turned into anime, like Akira, Berserk, Monster, Ghost in the Shell, Death Note, One Punch Man. But even some of those end up going downhill or failing to evolve out of the "edgy and violent" stage, e.g. Attack on Titan.

    Clearly the garbage is what makes money, which is a huge shame.

    And AFAIK Hayao Miyazaki does not like to be associated with the Anime genre and would prefer being grouped with the likes of Disney. And I think that's quite appropriate.

    • You might enjoy Oshi no ko.
      .I actually wasnt aware of OPM being seinen. Felt like a good paced shonen and slap-stick humor

      • I'll check it out.

        Not sure how definitive that OPM classification is, but I see OPM as a seinen that deconstructs shonen via satire. It presents the absurdity of the superhero endgame with a troubled god-like protagonist. It also redefines what it means to be a hero in a realistic and inspiring way (via Mumen Rider).

  • I can't put my finger on it. I keep trying to watch it, but it always loses my interest. The plots sound amazing but there's something in the style that pushes me away.

  • I guess we just grew up and Japan still mostly treats and creates anime as media for kids and teenagers, not unlike how cartoons are still mostly "for kids".

    I don't "hate" anime, like many people here, but some stuff just doesn't entertain me anymore. I'm too old to find Dragon Ball Z and every other similar shonen even minimally entertaining. Hell, I was probably too old for that shit back when I was 19, I remember checking Bleach and giving up on episode 7 or whatever, though I think it was Naruto that "woke me up" when I was 16, I was watching it but wasn't enjoying it for quite a while, until I just dropped it around ep 120, "this shit ain't going nowhere".

    I've only watched Evangelion the first time during covid years, and it was clear it was two stories in one: the one they wanted to tell, which was kinda interesting, and their struggles with budget and how that affected the product.

    The thing is that the anime that reaches mass appeal is meant for the masses, much like movies with mass appeal are the ones that require you to shut down your brain. The last 2 anime that I watched, enjoyed and wouldn't mind watching again are Legend of Galactic Heroes and Taxi Driver, both are low on nonsense and bullshit.

    More often than not, it's just better to read the manga, when the anime's based on one. Slam Dunk is a much better read than watching the anime, plus you end up knowing about the author's other work, Vagabond, which is amazing.

  • Edit: I'm sorry for the lack of tl; dr. There's a general drop off of quality, weird social media garbage, a lot of systemic problems, etc. What I'm trying to say here is hard to summarize

    Aside from the fact that it's mass produced garbage, I can actually say that I'm old enough to have experienced a period of anime where the production values, writing, and dialogue weren't exactly terrible.

    I think a good example of my gripe with anime today is watching something like Fate Zero and then following that up with Heaven's Feel. The distinct drop in quality between those 2 adaptations is pretty stark.

    The original Yu-Gi-Oh anime was absolutely wild. It's dumb in a uniquely entertaining fashion. There were so many sequels that were produced for Yu-Gi-Oh and every single one of them was completely terrible.

    Watching Tenchi Muyo's OVA part 1 and part 2 was fairly enjoyable. Part 3 is so much worse for seemingly no good reason.

    The third Tenchi Muyo film was abjectly terrible. It's quite possibly one of the worst films that has ever been made.

    FLCL season 1 was legendary. Season 2 and 3 were substantially worse.

    The new Evangelion films weren't exactly great.

    Even as far back as Pokemon season 1, that season was pretty okay. Almost everything past the first 2 seasons were.... really bad....

    There have been some bad adaptions for Berserk that have been mentioned from time to time.

    Dragonball Super is weird. Nobody really seems to like Super. Even people who watch Super regularly treat it as some kind of Frankenstein monster.

    Gundam has been pretty consistently not good for well over a decade. Gundam Wing was pretty insane. It started off with some super questionable writing and poor voice acting, and then it ended off being probably the best thing Gundam has ever been. And everything that followed was.... not very good...

    Naruto was followed by Boruto. It's pretty bad. A large chunk of the 2nd half of Naruto was just not good.

    I've seen people defend Hunter X Hunter's Chimera Ant arc so brazenly. And still, it's genuinely not good. Which is amazing, because almost everything prior to that arc was crazy good.

    To be fair, a lot of these problems stem from the fact that the work being adapted is also consistently worse. It's not just anime. A lot of this coincides with the same drop in quality in the manga industry as well.

    The nearly universal drop in quality across the anime and manga industries has been... frustrating...

    Even more frustrating is the overwhelming number of fake reviews, shilling, bot spam, etc that are meant to hide negative reviews about anime and pretty much anything involving Japanese media.

    The amount of weird shit that gets posted to review sites and social media in order to hide the general negativity towards the anime industry is just gross and weird.

    Another poster, Ace T'Ken, brought up a lot of specifics about the problems with anime in general. It's a pretty good write-up, imo.

    My take is, I think that these problems are more "noticeable" in modern anime. But, almost all anime have these kinds of problems to one degree or another, new and old.

    It's pretty systemic. I still think that these issues became a lot more noticeable coinciding with a general drop in quality across the whole industry.

    I would like to say, it's not like I dislike anime "inherently". But, there's just so much bad anime.

  • Hate is a strong word. But I have never really cared for it. The content I have watched felt like it was the trillby wearing "um actually" kid writing his own edgey story. And something about the yelling outbursts I have seen a few times make me want to curl up and die.

  • Even though I kinda like the aesthetics, especially for AI image generation, and I'm a kind of a nerd (it's popularly said that nerds like animes), I don't like nor hate, I simply don't care to know and watch animes. Not only animes, but also animated movies and series, as well as mangas.

  • Chiming in as someone who actually owns a few different anime on DVD/blu-ray.

    My whole thing is that I like good media. Anime is a medium. There's good anime out there. As many have already said, those're few and far between because the vast majority of people working in the medium seem determined to pigeonhole it as genre trash and perv shit.

    I kinda stopped watching anime early in my 20s. The late 00s into the 10s seemed like the absolute worst period of time for worthwhile anime being made. I've sat through a few more current big-name ones since then and shit hasn't improved.

    So yeah, I don't hate anime as a medium, I just hate like 99% of the medium's content

92 comments