"It's Communism": Kamala's First Economic Plan Proposes Price Controls To "Combat Inflation"
ZeroHedge - On a long enough timeline, the survival rate for everyone drops to zero
You're viewing a single thread.
I can’t imagine a world where I would post that link seriously.
Why? It's all over Google: https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-1-d&q=price+controls+kamala+harris Isn't communism what you wanted? Communism is price controls historically. In actual practice, prices don't exist, or matter, in communism, because like socialism, it's predecessor, it is not an economy, but a society that gifts things based on altruism.
Communism is not price controls, Jesus. It's the state seizing assets from wealthy people and nationalizing businesses. Regulating how businesses can operate in a capitalist system is nothing new. You could call it socialism and even that's a stretch.
How do you have price controls without prices? Price regulation is explicitly a phenomenon in market economies.
@Amoxtli @tacosanonymous Maybe he doesn't trust #WaPo, #Time, #CNBC, #TheHill, #NBCNews, or #ABCNews
https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2024/08/15/kamala-harris-economic-policy-2024/
https://time.com/7011214/kamala-harris-campaign-federal-ban-price-gouging-food-groceries-inflation/
https://www.cnbc.com/2024/08/15/harris-corporate-price-gouging-ban-food-election.html
https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4828758-kamala-harris-federal-ban-price-gouging/
https://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/harris-zeroing-high-food-prices-inflation-remains-big-112860716
Uh, those links don't say it's "Communism" which is the problem with the one OP posted. Nobody said this story wasn't true. It's the idiotic "let's scare some ignorant rubes, it's communism!!" angle. The Democratic party isn't even remotely communist, unfortunately.
@zeppo Sigh...you're going to argue that price controls aren't characteristic of #Communism, aren't you?
Brittanica describes price controls as non-capitalistic:
https://www.britannica.com/money/price-system/Noncapitalist-price-systems
Sigh... uh, yeah. Communist countries control prices and economic activity to a far greater degree. Like, so much more that it's absurd to claim that, which is the point here. The link also barely says what you claim it does.
@zeppo Would you agree that, generally, #Communism usually controls prices, and #Capitalism usually does not?
Yes, but that's an incredibly simplistic point of view. Plenty of capitalist economies also have limits on prices. In the US, over 40 states already have price gouging laws on the books for years, going back to 1979. The EU has enacted various statutes to control prices of consumer goods as well. You could call it socialist, perhaps... but it's also kind of silly to think that capitalism means unbridled capitalism with no regulation. That's never been how it worked. When the US nationalizes Walmart, Kroger and ConAgra let me know.
@zeppo I completely agree with you here. We are not in a pure, Capitalist society. Right now, we are in what is known as a mixed market economy.
However, I would posit that we are closer to the free market model than a planned economy, and the farther away we move from the free market model, the closer we get to a planned economy. It doesn't mean that we're there already, but, in general, moving away from the free market model sets off red flags for those worried ending up in a planned economy.
Yeah, uh... so what do you think about subsidies on major agricultural products such as corn, wheat and beef? Should we cancel all of that?
@zeppo I'd have to look more into what the impacts of such a policy would be but I certainly support cancelling those subsidies on principle.
and this is how the starvation starts. With caps on prices, it becomes unprofitable and they just reduce supply. Talk to any survivors of communism and low food supplies has always been an issue.
Record profits from grocery stores and food suppliers. But please, tell me more about how they can't afford to drop prices and it would be unprofitable.
Keep in mind, unprofitable means going into the red; not just making less profit than the previous quarter. Infinite growth is an insane philosophy, especially for basic goods.
@aniki @wintermuteoregon "Only mean people have healthy margins in their business ventures" is the quintessential terminally online take
Healthy margins ≠ record profits
@agamemnonymous Record profits ≠ bad
Record inflation is though, and makes all the nominal profits numbers go up without adding any extra underlying value to the companies balance sheets.
@nicholas @agamemnonymous The real reason we're seeing record profits is that big businesses are preparing cash stockpiles ahead of the inevitable economic collapse that financial experts and insiders are all expecting, but nobody wants to talk about that.
My common response to the "corporate greed" accusation is asking if squirrels are greedy for hoarding acorns for the winter.
When they're hoarding billions of acorns, leaving little for the other squirrels, then yes.
@agamemnonymous Which is what all squirrels would do if they could 🤷🏾♂️
You realize that food producers in a communist nation wouldn’t be supposed to make profits, right? The problems with that in various countries were from poorly done central planning.
It's an inherent flaw in communism. People starve under the system.
Source? Communism has never been implemented, and the systems designed to transition to communism, e.g. the USSR, we're actually pretty successful in decreasing hunger. People starve under capitalism.
Yes, it has. Venezuela, Cuba, the soviet block.
Starvation was common under the Soviets.
https://www.historyhit.com/why-did-the-soviet-union-suffer-chronic-food-shortages/
Talk to anyone who survived communism. It is a common theme. That is why one of my friends defected. He came to America and saw a grocery store.
Not any more than it is under capitalism. People starve under that system too. Meanwhile you have Republicans crying that a state might pay $1.50 a day to feed a needy kid lunch at school. Why is that even necessary then?
My friends who survived communism would disagree with you. Do you have a cite to show otherwise?
Looking at Venezuela, I have not seen anything like that here, have you? or Cuba? When I was in Cuba, malnutrition was common.
Do I have a citation that starvation exists in capitalist countries as well? I don't think comparing the rest of the world to the US, which is extraordinarily well-positioned economically for a variety of reasons, makes much sense. Even so, we have 15-30 million people in the US who experience occasional or chronic food insecurity.
As far as Cuba, who knows how they would have done without decades of a US trade embargo. Venezuela has suffered under looting and misrule by authoritarian dictators, not communism.
Cuba is only embargoed from us. Pretty much everyone else in the world trades with them.
Authoritarian dictators. Communism. It is all the same thing.
@wintermuteoregon @Amoxtli To be fair to the others, this isn't technically #Socialism or #Communism, it's a #MixedMarket. Problem is that you're also right, this is how we drift away from #Capitalism.
The left wingers in the thread aren't upset that this is being called out because it's inaccurate, it's because they want #Communism but understand that #Communism is scary to the masses because of its past failures.