Skip Navigation

Games @sh.itjust.works

nanoUFO @sh.itjust.works

10mo ago

IGN

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree DLC Review (10/10)

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree DLC Review - IGN

PC Gaming @lemmy.ca

alessandro @lemmy.ca

10mo ago

10/10

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree DLC Review - IGN

www.ign.com /articles/elden-ring-shadow-of-the-erdtree-dlc-review

35 comments

20-25 hour campaign
That's like... 120 hours for me the way I meticulously comb every inch of playable area. And die a lot.
- I have 306 hours in Elden Ring and I think 250+ of that was me wandering and killing minor bosses.
  
  I've got about 200 hours each on just my first 3 characters on PC. And I have the game on PS5, too.
  Game's alright, I guess.
- my brother.

It’s IGN. They probably had this score lined up since the announcement.
- Eh, I don’t love IGN but it seems like at this point nothing they do makes people happy. I remember when they gave Starfield a 7 people rioted lol, even tho the score was entirely deserved.
  
  A seven is VERY generous for Starfield… but I know game review scores are BS and only go from 5-10.
  
  Were people angry because it was low or high? I'd give it a lower score personally, though I've still seen some people argue it's a perfect game
  I'd say it deserves a perfectly mediocre 5. Everything it does is better in other games, and the one thing it's supposed to do (exploration) is better in their other games. I live sci-fi so I was willing to overlook a lot of issues, but I think the biggest letdown is that the sci-fi stories it tells are boring as hell and don't actually make use of the genre. If they really wanted to make a sci-fi game they should have been ready to tell interesting sci-fi stories. Instead they gave up all the strengths of their other games to tell uninteresting stories.
  
  Bethesda should have put “Mario” or “Zelda” in the title if they wanted better scores from IGN.
  
  I believe you, but I don't remember backlash for that score on Starfield.

Can a DLC be game of the year?
- Maybe? Witcher 3: Blood & Wine was similar.

I have a character sitting at the table at the end of the game before starting up another round of Ng+, will that work for the DLC? Or does it have to be before the fire giant?
- I watched a couple of prep videos from people who played the 3 hour demo and they said just have a dude who's beaten the game but hasn't moved to journey 2.
  I have a few in that state already, but I'm also wondering if there is a cut off trigger. Like if the final boss is dead, can I still go into the DLC? Or even if I can, if there are new ending conditions to change the ending can I obtain them? Technically I've already committed to an ending and seen the credits roll; I just haven't moved to J2 at the Roundtable.
  
  Yeah. I ran through every main ending with the same character, and I think this last one was the Age of Stars ending. I don't mind starting up a new journey to get to the DLC, I'd just rather get it out of the way so I can just straight into it when it releases. Thursday is my day off, and I'd rather not waste all of the time I have to play on rehashing the old stuff.
- I think all we know is you have to have beaten ::: spoiler spoiler Radahn and Mohg ::: to get in.
  
  Yeah. I'm just hoping there isn't a cut off after you have completed other parts of the story. Guess I'll find out in a day and a half. Worse comes to worse I beeline it in a new run.

It has a little something for everyone.
- Ultrawide support? If there were no new content, I would pay just for the ultrawide support.

35 comments