Poland bans sale of energy drinks to under-18s
Poland bans sale of energy drinks to under-18s
Producers or importers who fail to properly label energy drinks can be fined up to 200,000 zloty (€44,677).
You're viewing a single thread.
I hope this would also include products like "5 hour energy", which are energy drinks, but in a smaller and even easier to shot down package.
Permanently Deleted
"excluding products where those substances occur naturally."
That seems like a dumb exception. It's not like naturally occurring caffeine is somehow better for you. If it's above that limit, then the law should apply to that as well.
It's a lot easier to pass a law banning the sale of artificial drinks to minors than it is to ban coffee sales to minors.
Artificial drinks, not caffeine? Coffee is artificial drink too because it is human-made.
It nearly impossible to define energy-drinks in a way that does not include coffee, but include off-the-shelf drinks.
Coffee has its beans dried and roasted, then ground and seeped in water. If you're going to call that artificial, then you are claiming that literally any cooked food is also artificial.
Coffee has its beans dried and roasted
Coffee beans are dried. Then beans then ungo a Maillard reaction, caramelisation, pyrolysis and decarboxilation to form new organic componds
then ground and seeped in water
Then ground to maximize the surface area. The prouder is then extracted using unpure H2O as solvent. A higher temperature is needed to raise the solubility of the compounds.
You can describe anything that's consumed by people with chemical terms and it's gonna sound unnatural.
You remind me of that old joke site warning people of the dangers of the chemical compound DHMO (dihydrogen monoxide)
Yeah that's basically the point I try to make. You can't even say it's not synthetic since you're synthezise new compounds in the first step. There really is no real difference artificial and natural.
Let's take Vanillin (vanilla flavoring) for example: you could extract it from Vanilla, but it's pretty expensive this way. You could also just synthesize it from wood pulp and get the exact same compound. It's not even just similar, no, it's the exact same.
If something is natural or "artifical" doesn't say anything about how harmful it is.
And you are correct.
For those who think energy drinks are not the same, please point out at which stage coffee is no longer coffee and why:
- Make coffee
- Filter it
- Evaporate more water
- Add sugar
I'm gonna go with the step you didn't list which is soaking them in dichloromethane or ethyl acetate for several hours, or submersing them in high pressure, supercritical carbon dioxide, to extract the pure caffeine. Then adding that pure caffeine into a mixture of artificial sugars, preservatives, and food dyes.
But sure, that's totally the same as something that's essentially a type of tea.
submersing them in high pressure, supercritical carbon dioxide
Whoa! Didn't know you can boil in CO2 too.
artificial sugars
Nah, too expensive.
Yes, supercritical is a point where a aß s
Whoa! Didn't know you can boil in CO2 too.
You can under high enough pressure
I would argue that naturally occurring caffeine is much worse than synthetic caffeine because it also contains rest of plant's toxins and other not so good stuff.
On the other hand not that anyone uses sunthetic caffeine in their drinks. It is expensive as hell.
Those kind of things aren't really popular outside of America. I only ever see them in America
Seen them in Thailand. Red Bull was originally in small shot format.cam from there, and it was adapted for other markets.
The Thai family of the pharmacist who came up with the formula still owns 50% of Red Bull.
It’s from Thailand and company is from Austria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Bull_GmbH?wprov=sfti1