Linux @lemmy.ml woelkchen @lemmy.world 7 mo. ago

Gnome's Adwaita team is breaking icon compatibility

How it shall look… # Linux & BSDs # Windows # macOS # State on Fedora 40 Workstation & XFCE Spin… # Screenshots taken from the GNOME bugtracker, copies to not stall their GitLab instance.

Hacker News @lemmy.smeargle.fans bot @lemmy.smeargle.fans

BOT

7 mo. ago

The Adwaita Icon Theme no longer follows the FDO spec, breaking e.g. KDE apps

cullmann.io /posts/kate-and-icons/

KDE @lemmy.kde.social Christoph Cullmann @lemmy.kde.social 7 mo. ago

The Adwaita Icon Theme no longer follows the FDO icon naming spec breaking KDE applications on Fedora 40 Workstation and Co.

cullmann.io /posts/kate-and-icons/

You're viewing a single thread.

74 comments

Permanently Deleted
- Is being a massive cunt a requirement if you want to be a GNOME developer?
  
  Yep.
  
  It's in the SOW.
- Familiarity breeds contempt, give it some time and I'm sure cosmic will have its share of haters too. There's hundreds of gnome devs, and all you're seeing are clickbait blogposts like these made to stir up the pot. Go check out the discussions on discourse, matrix, or even gitlab to see what they're actually like.
  
  Permanently Deleted
  
  The problem isn't that every gnome dev is bad - not by a long shot. The problem is that there are just enough gnome devs in just the right (wrong?) positions who have an "our way or the highway" philosophy that it causes problems not just for people trying to use GNOME, but for people (such as the Kate developers) who are trying to give their users a good experience.
  
  And by being the default in so many distros, GNOME has enough clout that if they choose to abandon a standard, many people will change to whatever GNOME does, making their applications worse for people on other desktops.
  
  In the end it's not too dissimilar to the problems created by the dominance of Chromium and Windows. The biggest difference IMO is that Google are actually more conciliatory towards others than the GNOME team are in many cases. Which is kinda crazy given how much Google can throw their weight around on the web.
  
  Google has a swath of PR people, devs are always going to be less socially inclined. Devs at google aren't the ones making the decisions. But yeah gnome does throw its weight around, both for good and bad.
  
  I've interacted directly with gnome devs and they live with their heads in the sand.
  
  I’ve interacted directly with gnome devs and they were entirely reasonable and respectful.
  
  But they're so nice, friendly and engaging! (lol)
  
  What does that even mean?
- That's because Cosmic is made by really cool people at System76 who actually care about their users/customers and the broader open source Linux desktop ecosystem
- I can't wait to throw it on my laptop. I hope the tiling is highly customizable because I need something I can throw on a laptop, not update in a while and still have it not break when I finally do.
  
  I like Hyperland but it does break the config every once and a while.
- GNOME is a much larger group. Plenty of times do they interact with KDE people…

You've viewed 74 comments.