I wanna be a Xitter Idiot

Like a lot of fascism, it makes perfect sense if you understand the code words. "Inserting politics" or "getting political" means expressing a disallowed opinion that should be silenced. You'll never hear this kind of language used about the approved opinions, only the to-be-silenced ones.
- Exactly this.
  Kneeling for the anthem is inserting politics into sports, playing the anthem before the game? Not at all inserting politics into sports.
  Pride night? Not allowed. First responder (read: cop) Night? Totally cool.
  
  If first responder night was just fire department and EMT itd be infinitely better, fun fact a bar in my city banned that type of event since the fire chief nearly got into a fight with the police chief.
  
  "I stand for the flag. I kneel for the cross." --A phrase uttered only by people who have never once knelt in front of a cross, ever.
  I've also noticed a direct correlation between people who wave around "Blue Lives Matter" flags and people who think police officers should essentially be paid poverty level wages. They're often the same group of people. And yes, the irony is completely lost on them.
  Now I have to tell a story. And this actually happened. Eons ago, I got a wild hair and decided to run for my local city council. At that time, the city was pushing a small tax increase to fund raises for the police and fire departments, where the average salary was like $9/hr for a patrolman. It was not a great wage even then. I literally had people with "thin blue line" bumper stickers yelling at me because "I make $9 an hour. Why should they be paid better than me?" I quickly learned that there is a large -- or larger than I would have expected -- percentage of the population that supports the "police" as a concept as long as it means they get to feel morally superior. When it comes to actually supporting the people who are the police, they don't give two shits.
  It's possible to think that police, firefighters, and other public servants in hazardous occupations should be compensated well AND be held to high moral and ethical standards. Mind blowing. I know.
- That's pretty well how it is basically any time someone's trying to make another shut up. It doesn't even need to be politics.

For context, original lyrics:
Don't wanna be an American idiot
Don't want a nation under the new media
And can you hear the sound of hysteria?
The subliminal mind fuck America
Welcome to a new kind of tension
All across the alienation
Where everything isn't meant to be okay
Television dreams of tomorrow
We're not the ones who're meant to follow
For that's enough to argue
Well maybe I'm the faggot America
I'm not a part of a redneck agenda
Now everybody do the propaganda
And sing along to the age of paranoia
Welcome to a new kind of tension
All across the alienation
Where everything isn't meant to be okay
Television dreams of tomorrow
We're not the ones who're meant to follow
For that's enough to argue
Don't want to be an American idiot
One nation controlled by the media
Information age of hysteria
It's calling out to idiot America
Welcome to a new kind of tension
All across the alienation
Where everything isn't meant to be okay
Television dreams of tomorrow
We're not the ones who're meant to follow
For that's enough to argue
Super tame.
In the New Year's show, they changed "a redneck agenda" to "the MAGA agenda". Okay, little bit more explicitly partisan, but basically the same thing.
- And yet, as a leftist redneck, I whole heartedly approve of the change.
  Feel a little more seen, even if it doesn't mean anything.
  
  I've known many rednecks who were good people. If you aren't hurting people, you do you, friend! Also, chunk those punkins!
- “a redneck agenda” to “the MAGA agenda”
  If MAGA as a name for these people had existed then, they would have used it. They're the same people.
  
  Hashtagnotallrednecks.
- I think part of the problem (aside from people that don't ever listen to the words in songs) is less that the song/green day is apolitical in their interpretation, but more that for a lot of people the word "politics" means partisan politics. Being explicitly about a party or one of their core issues is what makes something *𝓅𝑜𝓁𝒾𝓉𝒾𝒸𝒶𝓁* to them.
  
  What is and is not political is defined by oppressors. Their crosses, punisher skulls, and blue lives matter stickers are not political. The atheist symbol, antifa arrows, and black lives matter stickers are political. A keffiyeh is a political statement, but an IDF shirt isn't. "Political" functionally means "talking about your oppression or the oppression of others."
  
  JSYK, using special characters to write “political” like that doesn’t work with screen readers. Best case scenario it skips the word entirely, worst case it reads out the name of each special character individually.
  
  Yeah. It’s fucking sad.
- It's tame by today's standards but at the time it got quite a few people in a tizzy
  
  Yeah it was before bush was re-elected during the age of prime jingoism
- Well that change in lyrics certainly got the point across. 😂
- Was f##got broadcast uncensored over the air?
  
  It was not
  
  Mindless self indulgence?
- Have they changed the removed part yet? It's uh, pretty not great.
  
  As the other commenter said, it's not derogatory. He's taking a word that's been used to belittle and dismiss him and people that share his views, owning it, and using it to fire back against those that would use it against him in that way.
  Basically, "Call me gay* (ok, like that's supposed to be a bad thing? Watch me call myself gay lol) but at least I'm not a dumb idiot follower of the redneck/MAGA agenda."
  To me, it's like a more sophisticated "I know you are but what am I?", if you will. He's so unphased by the label that he uses it for himself with little hesitation, thus stripping its power as an insult against him. Hence why he fires back with a new, more critical put-down. It's meant to hit them (someone that would call someone else gay or a faggot* as an insult) where it hurts, in the same way that person has meant to hurt others by using those terms derogatorily. He's literally naming and shaming the bigotry of the time.
  *And yes I know the term faggot has some nasty origins, but it was colloquially just a much more rude/derogatory way to say "gay person" when this song came out. I highly doubt the majority of people that used it were actually thinking that critically about it. The song itself at least very clearly does not mean it in the original sense.
  
  The guy singing it is openly bisexual so it’s not bad imo
  
  You should hear him sing King for a Day.

It’s the rage against the machine all over again. Shows how truly dumb people are. Like do they even listen to the lyrics?
- I doubt they're even real people. This sniffs of a Russian campaign.
  
  The line between russian propagandists and MAGA idiots is indistinguishable.
  
  Republicans are that stupid though so I can see some being real.
  
  Nah, I've got a family member who voted for trump and loves RatM. They honestly think the lyrics support conservative ideals, and advocate for violence against people who would change the country from the "good ol' days."
  
  I hope you don't mind Unix systems, cuz you should avoid Windows after a statement like that.
- I die a little inside every time someone gets offended by Money For Nothing.
  
  But he’s wearing an EAR RING AND MAKE UP!!!
  That’s his own hair, for Christ sakes!!!
- "what did you think they were raging against? The dishwasher?"
- "Fuck off, I'm not doing it"
  something like that isn't it?

Politics? In my Green Day?
_It's _more _likely _than _you _think.
- It's funny - I agree with Green Day in most ways politically, but stopped listening after American Idiot because so much of their music was blatantly political. That's what they were going for, it is CLEAR and OBVIOUS to anyone listening to their music, where they stand. I am all for it, I would just rather be escaping the world's issues while listening to music :)
  
  Dude, they're a punk band, or at least they were. That's literally the point of the genre
  
  I quit listening to Green Day because it was impossible to escape When September Ends. Couldn't go out in public without hearing it somewhere.
  
  Maybe punk just isn't your thing
  
  All art is political
  
  It's funny to me...I didn't say they were bad, I didn't say I didn't like them, I didn't say anything except for that they clearly took their music in a more in your face, political direction. That's fine, I support them making that choice. I get that punk is inherently political, and that most music has hints of it. When I started listening, when 1039 came out - I was too young to understand what the music was about. Then came kerplunk and dookie. Dookie has many songs that are just about boredom, wasting time, or girls. Same thing for Insomniac and Nimrod. You cannot argue that EVERY song on those albums was political, it's just not true. They became a pop-punk alternative band. That's great, they still make great music, I just choose other styles and genres. Downvotes aren't hurting me, but it seems excessive for sharing my thoughts.
  For the record, I was a ride or die fan in the 90's. 5 shows, one of them I waited by the outdoor stage for 3 hours to get a good spot. I had my art featured on the earliest version of their website, back in the AOL days. I still love the music I grew up with. Bands style, peoples preferences change...I just don't want to think about the broken world when I listen to music anymore.

He's the one who likes
All our pretty songs and he
Likes to sing along and he
Likes to shoot his gun but he
Don't know what it means
- Yaaaaaa

It’s like they interpret music as just a noise that sounds appealing with no meaning.
- Fuck you I won't do what you tell me!
  No idea on the rest of the lyrics, something about forces and crosses. I wasn't really listening. I like crosses! Woo, Trump!
  
  I guess this is the best place for this comment: about two years back my friend (who is a hardcore conservative, just not trump is God crazy and he doesn't know about qanon), myself and two other guys (they're all moderate or liberal) went to go see Rage Against The Machine for like the first time in 20 years. During one of the songs where he raps about humans living shitty lives because they can get ahead, there were posters all over saving things like "save the kids ". "feed the children".
  My conservative buddy looked at me during the time the posters were up and was he like "WTF is this shit?*
  
  They should have kept "hold office". The rhyme works better, "works forces" isn't a saying so it seems really forced, and apparently no one would have noticed anyway.
- Hence former House Speaker and Ayn Rand-lover Paul Ryan's favorite band being Rage Against The Machine
  
  This is also why the Snyder Superman movies are bad.
  Superman is an illegal alien who learned the value of kindness and hard work from his adopted parents, uses his powers to help people because it's the right thing to do, and spends the time that he's not being Superman to do investigative journalism that exposes corruption.
  Snyder is an objectivist who understands precisely 0% of any of that, and that's why his Superman movies completely fail to be about anything.
- That's how they interpret all art.
- I dont see that as an issue so long as you aren't gonna attempt shaming them. I have songs I just listen to but couldn't tell you a single lyric or who it is.
  
  Yea that’s all fine but when they get surprised that Green Day has a little something more to say after preforming American idiot it’s a bit funny.

We found him, its the American Idiot!
- Those names don't look very American, or real
  
  America is a nation of immigrants. So how on earth would an "American name" look like? They are literally the most american names possible without being indiginous.
  
  The top one (Vas) looks to be Greek and the other looks to be Polish.
  
  Yours is even worse, kiddo. Put down the stones.

You don't get to get away from it. MAGA politics has made life a living hell for so many people that can't get away from it, and the only thing anyone can do is confront you with it every waking moment of yours.
- The joke is that the song is inherently political, even before the language change to be current, and even without that change the song is explicitly about those people anyway.
  
  I realize that.
  
  What language change to be current?

Maybe conservatives just take a sharpie and put a comma on the album cover so it says "American, Idiot" as in they are yelling at someone that they are American and that they should have known by their ignorant angry voice.

American Idiot was already political and already critical of the Republicans. I guess all these American idiots didn't know the lyrics before?
- "He's the one
  who likes all our pretty songs
  and he likes to sing along
  and he likes to shoot his gun
  but he knows not what it means"
  
  reminds me of the line in Hey Ya! by OutKast:
  "y'all don't wanna hear me, you just wanna dance"

Anyone who wants to censor culture is a fascist at their core. In a liberal democracy you can say anything but you're not immune from the consequences.
That being said these users look fake AF and we should stop pretending Twitter/x/whatever is anything but a dead forum
- Unfortunately they're not only NOT fake, but irl they're just as disgruntled and morally ugly as their online persona. Me and a friend finally got ourselves blocked by one common mutual who was behaving like that even in public and we couldn't help but either A) block his stupid "centrist" hypocrite ass and never go out with him again or B) mock him, call him out and make fun of him for every unhinged thing he would say. We chose B and we had some good laughs upon his stupidity
- Right, exactly that's the reason everyone should be allowed to say the nword.
  
  Say it if you like. Doesn't reflect well on you if you do decide to.
  
  -__-
  
  You can say the N word all you want. No law against it. Just prepare to get punched in the mouth a lot.

That X is pronounced "sh" right?
- Found the 15th century Spaniard
  
  Or any century Chinese.
- I was thinking "fr"....
- I think so yes but I can't not read it ckzitter lol

Incredible that they can just keep coming up with shit like this day after day, indefinitely. Truly astonishing
- Every other argument they have is instantly demolished because of how stupid they are so they just reach into the barrel to scrape out more shit. But the problem is that they're not just scraping the bottom, they've gone and dug a hole halfway to China.

Guy who shocked by green day probably never existed back in 2004 or just want a piece of cake for attention. Green Day always has been political in some of their song release since Warning(?), even on The Network side project ~~am I supposed to think The Network is Green Day?~~ Am no American and enjoyed Green Day from Dookie to Revolution Radio (not really listened to them since FOaMF release).
- Warning was my fav album by them. And dookie
  
  Agreed. No matter which era you like whether 90s Green Day or Post-American Idiot album, Green Day still great band and great live performer, their live performance are treat especially when they were playing faster live. You can see them on youtubes, my favorite is live version of Paper Lantern (specifically Chicago 1994)

Making fun of the people who didn't like the political statement is fine, and there were plenty of high profile people to dunk on for that, but this is literally some rando this person searched up, the original tweet had basically no interactions. This could even be satire for all we know.
Effectively, if not possibly literally, nobody really said this.
- The whole "the right is up in arms" is bullshit. I'm sure there are idiots who say some stupid things, but I have conservative relatives. I get (unwillingly) exposed to war room more than I care to say. The only place I've heard about it is in posts like this.
- Did GPT write that for you?

Punks and politics are like peas and carrots.

Does anyone think people like that do this on purpose?

Image Transcription: Twitter Posts
PStarzynski Discruntled Rangers/NYY Fan, @PeterS_Tech
You know the more I thought about it, why did Green Day have to insert politics into their performance of American Idiot? We're trying to get away from that for a few hours.
Vas Drimalitis, @vasdrimalitis
"Why did Green day have to insert politics into their performance of American Idiot" is a truly incredible sentence to read.

You xweet is why.