Skip Navigation

Good job everyone blocking and boycotting .ml! It's having an effect, users are noticing and MAUs on their comms are falling!

And for anyone asking "Why are we boycotting/blocking lemmy.ml?" Here's a quick recap:

Lemmy.ml is an instance run by admins who are hardcore tankies and will enforce their ideology on their instance through various means from allowing (and pushing it themselves) propaganda (Such as Russia being justified in some way to invade Ukraine) and known propaganda outlets (Like RT) to removing content on their instance critical of their favored authoritarian regimes such as Russia or China and even banning users for such speech or speech critical of them if it's off their instance (Just like the Reddit mods of ol!).

If it was just some random instance it would have been defederated from long ago like the rest of the "Tankie Triad" (Hexbear and Lemmygrad), but they've positioned lemmy.ml as the "flagship" instance and abused that position and influence to become large enough to keep other instances from defederating from them.

Which I believe is harmful to the Lemmy-verse's overall growth and outside reputation. I have seen it come up before on Reddit threads (and other testimonials from people who came back and tried it again) that "They tried Lemmy but it was a bunch of tankies and went back to Reddit"

I don't know about you, but I'd prefer Lemmy to not end up with the reputation for being "Tankie Central " or even worse "Voat 2.0".

So if you haven't joined the boycott yet, join today and help us foster a better healthier Lemmy-verse!

You can take a look around here on !meanwhileongrad@sh.itjust.works for documentation of it or checkout this list of curated documentation

On bans and censorships:

https://lemmy.world/post/28480760

https://lemmy.world/post/28481615

https://lemmy.world/post/28482147

https://lemmy.world/post/28480936

https://lemmy.world/post/28482273

https://lemmy.world/post/28481272

https://lemmy.world/post/28481064

https://lemmy.world/post/27674360

https://lemmy.world/post/27674117

https://lemmy.world/post/27673934

https://lemmy.world/post/27673724

https://lemmy.world/post/27577337

https://lemmy.world/post/27378634

https://lemmy.world/post/27346630

https://lemmy.world/post/27341283

https://lemmy.world/post/27288224

https://lemmy.world/post/27156418

https://lemmy.world/post/27054157

https://lemmy.world/post/27008261

Allowing altered headlines and permitting known propaganda outlets:

https://lemmy.world/post/28275465

https://lemmy.world/post/27428838

https://lemmy.world/post/27416097

https://lemmy.world/post/27314050

https://lemmy.world/post/27288953

Spreading Russia talking points like the Ukraine invasion just being a "negotiating tactic" !https://lemmy.world/post/27012640

General negative sentiment to other instances who haven't "seen the way" yet: https://lemmy.world/post/27426510

Open declaration of support for Russia (direct from dessalines (head admin)) https://lemmy.world/post/27352415

"concentration camps were just reeducation camps and weren't that bad" https://lemmy.world/post/26985447

148 comments
  • I joined Lemmy in November. By New Years I had independently figured out what was wrong with .ml and its users.

    The less of that garbage, the better.

  • cause nobody wants to get dragged into a ten page discussion about why China and Russia are the most democratic countries in the world

  • Thanks for the recap. I kinda get the instance federation stuff, but not fully. I realize they are flagship or whatever, but it aint like its that big a ship, even on the biggest one. Is there any consideration of defederating them now?

  • I think the whole "saying anything different from what we like? You're banned" thing is also playing a good part.

    • I think they really have no idea how unpopular their viewpoint is. If you ever go and look around at "Lemmy" based on how it looks when hosted on .ml or Hexbear, it looks pretty dramatically different. I think part of the reason the mods are so aggressive with this kind of censorship is that it creates a really surprisingly effective illusion that a lot of the world agrees with them. You can find off-instance communities where people post a counter-narrative if you search, but that's easy to write off as "the lib instances" or something. I think they have no idea how far in the minority they are.

      The name for the cognitive bias involved is "what you see is all there is." Your brain doesn't take account of content which is hidden from you, so if 90% of what you see is pro-Russia, and everyone there is of the opinion that anything outside of that is weird Western propaganda and distorted and fake, it's pretty easy for your brain to run with it. And once you're in that box you have no idea that you're in the box. And also, a lot of propaganda frameworks like that are self-sustaining (describing any contrary information as deliberate lies or giving this huge emotional emphasis to reasons for discounting them, so it's really hard to bootstrap yourself out of the box.)

      I'm not trying to make excuses for the people who are running the operation, I have to assume that they know better. Although, maybe not. Maybe they have some other kind of dysfunction and really think they are standing up against US imperialism or something. I do also think that professional troll farms are also involved in creating the impression, too. My point is, I think the average users may be genuinely confused by these events and see them very differently from the rest of Lemmy does.

      • "What do you mean people don't like us supporting imperialism? We made up our own definition of imperialism that excludes imperialist countries we like."

  • Yay another thread where .ml users will post so I can block them!

    Hopefully we can grow up as a community and defederate completely one day!

  • Thanks for the recap!

    Anyone wanna remind me how to block an entire instance? I’m on Fedia, if that matters.

  • Haha ok. I would never be happy sitting behind some blockade on the fediverse, unable to even see what others are saying. Its funny that you are so afraid of their opinions that you have to lock yourself in the basement. But you do you. :)

    • Yes, "Mao was good actually" is terrifying to me. It's such a fresh, novel, and revolutionary concept that I feel my mind unraveling every time I see a brave ml warrior post it. Same with "war is bad so Ukraine is bad for defending against invasion." The sheer intellect required to achieve such a unique understanding of these concepts is truly intimidating.

    • No one is afraid of their opinions. Everyone who has been on the fedi for a while has heard them, over, and over, and over. The mods, and the portion of the users who are grouped in with them, are campists who will defend anything places like China do, even if it is the exact same shit as the western imperialists. They also tend to spout a lot of apologia for harsh, punitive, legal systems, and police states, as long as it calls itself socialist. Hell, don't even need to do that anymore, just have to be like "hey NATO imperialism bad!" and they will come to defend the honor of a country that is actively annexing, and colonizing, other states, because imperialism is acceptable when it isn't the west. It is just them defending themselves, and/or liberating oppressed people, just like the US claims every time it bombs somewhere into the dirt. I have witnessed multiple instances of .ml users automatically dismissing any data from any source "western", while claiming you aren't capable of having a good faith argument, if you dismiss information from the CCP, in kind.

      I find that the large body of .ml users are not like this, but their mods, and a significant portion of the users, namely the most commonly seen names, are very much this way. There is no argument to be had, there is no fruitful discussion here. They are in their camp, and they can't seem to truly understand people can hate both camps, and actually not want what either offers. So why interact at this point?

    • Haha ok. I would never be happy sitting behind some blockade on the fediverse, unable to even see what others are saying.

      There's a difference between a veteran Lemming making a conscious choice to "see the other side for themselves" and a tentative-ex-Redditor checking the vibes of a new unknown place.

      Its funny that you are so afraid of their opinions that you have to lock yourself in the basement. But you do you. :)

      Lol, no. I've read their opinions, debated them multiple times even, and have come to the conclusion that their "opinions" are as toxic and/or dangerous misinformation as far-right "opinions". Authoritarianism is authoritarianism whether it's right or left shaded.

      If anything, I'm afraid of the potential damage it's doing to the Lemmy-verse.

      Every person that comes here, is another person Reddit has lost and another notch against corporate social media. And that's a beautiful thing worth protecting IMO

      • 100% agree with the last part. But misinformation is fought by having discussions about it, not by censoring it.

        You say you are afraid of the potential damage its doing to the fediverse. Well, now you have removed your voice from the discussions. They will still be there, even if you are not looking at them. You just walked away from it.

        You know when you "protect" kids by not talking about something, it only becomes more exciting to them? I dont know, I rather just talk to the kids about it. Have a laugh about how weird the world is together.

        And I agree, debating them is not really worth doing. But state your opinion and walk away. I have some unpopular opinions too that Lemmy doesnt like. But I keep saying them. Because i still think im right about those things. But im not going to debate for long. Its not worth our time.

  • Idk, I personally find that ML isnt that bad. Granted I may be a bit biased as a leftist but when I discuss my Anarchist positions I see significantly less censorship than world. Furthemore whenever I see massive Transphobic spam attacks its 9/10 from world. In addition I have had far more genuene conversations on ml communities and with ml users. However I cannot say the same for world users/communities which are known to shut down discussion by calling it "tankie" (yes even Anarchist discussion). Due to that it has become abundantly clear to me that the term "tankie" has very little if anything to do with authoritarianism and everything to do with leftism.

    • but when I discuss my Anarchist positions I see significantly less censorship than world.

      What kind of censorship are you seeing? I usually don't hang there so I've only really seen their liberalist "anti-violence" suppression of Brian Thompson posting. Which honestly is enough reason to avoid, but I'm curious.

      Also, agreeing from experience with the transphobia and hilarious ignorance of rabid anticommunists.

      • Generally that and "civility" anti revolutionary sentiment. It leads to people being more accepting of fascism than real antifascism.

    • Granted I may be a bit biased as a leftist but when I discuss my Anarchist positions I see significantly less censorship than world. Furthemore whenever I see massive Transphobic spam attacks its 9/10 from world.

      The modlog just doesn't reflect that, there's no widespread issue on .world as far as I've seen in all my time in the modlog.

      What I do see from .world is a bunch of moderators doing moderator things and very little admin actions, which is what you would expect from any instance of size. It's the opposite with .ml, and that should be a huge red flag in of itself.

      Are there bad mods and bad mod decisions? Sure, that's going to happen anywhere, but I don't see the .world admins in every comm across .world removing posts and comments critical of a certain agenda or to push a narrative, like on .ml.

      As far as "transphobic spam attacks" that can happen on any instance, .world being the biggest (literally double in size from the next biggest) means it's going to be targeted more. And again, I see it being dealt with accordingly in the modlog, in fact that's one of the main times I do see non-.ml admin actions in there, site banning actual bigots.

      Plus if .world really had a transphobe problem, ada would have defederated from it by now.

      However I cannot say the same for world users/communities which are known to shut down discussion by calling it "tankie" (yes even Anarchist discussion).

      Have you seriously not seen .ml tankies throw around "liberals" or "shitlibs" in the exact same way

      • Plus if .world really had a transphobe problem, ada would have defederated from it by now.

        Ada hasn't defederated from lemmy.ml despite the admin transphobia.

      • What I do see from .world is a bunch of moderators doing moderator things and very little admin actions

        Yeah that gets annoying when you're the moderator of a non-world community and I am. They rarely ban people and they allow anyone to make a new acc very easily.

        but I don't see the .world admins in every comm across .world removing posts and comments critical of a certain agenda or to push a narrative, like on .ml

        I keep seeing people say that but I havent personally seen that and I have said a lot against authoritarian regimes

        I see it being dealt with accordingly in the modlog, in fact that's one of the main times I do see non-.ml admin actions in there, site banning actual bigots

        I have been called a "self hating trans person" for being a leftist and had my entire gender invalided, called "fake" more times than I can count by world trolls and I have found nearly every time they were applauded.

        Plus if .world really had a transphobe problem, ada would have defederated from it by now.

        There are talks and serious considerations, many blahaj members want this

        Have you seriously not seen .ml tankies throw around "liberals" or "shitlibs" in the exact same way

        Tbh there are many times shitlib is more than justified and I see it very often. Common shitlib arguments include "we should compromise on the Israel-Palestine conflict, what if they only genocide half as many civilians?", "yeah I support Trans rights, but what if you gave up sports and trans youth as a compromise?", "yeah the system is rigged but if you dont vote blue no matter who you're not trying hard enough". Shitlib makes sense, it says you are a liberal and you are full of shit. Meanwhile tankie is just a blatant attempt to categorize the entire left as authoritarian.

    • significantly less censorship than world.

      Haven't been on this comm much eh?

      • I have, I have also seen world comms ban even mild critique of the Democrats. For people who claim to hate tankies y'all do enforce blind loyalty to the party quite often.

148 comments