China could sink all US carriers in 20 minutes, Pentagon chief warns
China could sink all US carriers in 20 minutes, Pentagon chief warns
interestingengineering.com
China could sink all US carriers in 20 minutes, Pentagon chief warns
68 comments
-
That would be shocking if true. The US takes its naval defences very seriously
-
During some war games a few years ago, the Dutch Navy managed to score a hit against a US Navy carrier using a diesel sub.
Like someone else said here, carriers are big, slow targets, it's not impossible for something to sneak past and sink them.
-
It was impressive but it happened in 1999. The Dutch Captain said that he doubted he could do it again and indeed a different Dutch Submarine failed at it the next year.
Carriers are considerable faster (30 Knots) than Diesel Subs (20 Knots) too, something the Dutch Captain touches on in that article.
-
Well in my mind few years ago was 1999...
Seriously though I thought this only happened within the last 10 years, TIL.
-
-
Diesel subs are also different kinds of beasts. They're terrible for international conflict, but for short range operations, they're silent. You can turn off a diesel engine, but not a nuclear reactor.
-
Has anyone tried making a reactor that can be turned off? Seems like an easy upgrade to make them silent in the short term.
-
I'd imagine it's not doable because of how quickly they'd develop insane amounts of heat.
-
-
-
Not in anyway an expert on matters naval, but diesel subs are pretty quiet running on electric motors. Nuclear reactors make more noise.
Feel free to correct me.
-
Point is, they're big, impossible to hide from anyone that has satellites, and you just need to get a lucky hit with a relatively cheap missile/torpedo to give the other side a multi-billion dollar loss in one go.
-
-
Carriers are actually some of the fastest ships out there because of nuclear propulsion.
-
-
against hypersonic missile (speed mach 5 to mach 25), good luck to spot it and try to destroy it before it reaches you
-
Most claimed "hypersonic" missiles can't actually manoeuvre at those speeds so you can spot them at distance and work out where you need to send an interceptor missile. We saw this with Patriot batteries vs Kinzhal in Ukraine.
-
Should be pretty easy to spot, those nose cones will be glowing in the atmosphere like rudolfs nose
-
-
68 comments